[net2-wg] Collection TEP draft

Omprakash Gnawali gnawali at usc.edu
Thu Feb 9 12:12:44 PST 2006


> Thanks Om, I like the proposal.
> 
>  A few specific comments:
> 
> ETX does not comply with the "higher number -> better quality" requirement.
> startRoot() and stopRoot() should not be in REControl, as they are
> moved into RootControl.
> 
> Thanks,
> Rodrigo

Yes, ETX does not comply with that higher number -> better quality
requirement. I think this is something we need to standardize because
if we are going to have different routing protocols running with a
given LinkEstimatorP, how do those routing protocols know if a link is
good or bad if it receives a quality of, lets say, 3 ? Did the link
get significantly better or marginally better if the quality now is 4
? I think we should standardize the output of getQuality() - in terms
of range, correlation of the return value and link
reliability/quality, and range.

Thanks for catching the problem re: REControl and RootControl.



More information about the net2-wg mailing list